Church Updates
Stay informed as we walk through important updates together.
MODEL CONVERSATION as of 11/19
On Tuesday, November 17, the Full Council of Elders (all elders from all Vintage locations) met for another installment of the model discussion, in preparation for a vote on December 2. This specific meeting was an opportunity to bring in staff, deacon, and member input, particularly with information those groups gained through our November 4 meeting with Zach Cochran. The conversation was both encouraging and clarifying, and the elders now have a general leaning that they will continue to contemplate. In the plan currently being considered, Vintage North would become an autonomous church while Vintage Downtown, Durham, and Chapel Hill would reorganize into a new cooperative structure. The emphasis falls on considered; the discussion process has yet another intentional step of input gathering and processing before a final decision will be reached.
The elders of Vintage North are unanimous in their opinion on both setting out as an autonomous church and maintaining strong ties with the locations that remain, both in long term relationship and in short term continued financial and organizational support. Regardless of the logistics, all Vintage elders desire this to be a loving and thoughtful planting of North.
Meanwhile, the elders of Downtown, Durham, and Chapel Hill are interested in further conversation about a new cooperative version of our multisite model, one that would maintain the strength of collaboration and mutual dependency while installing robust accountability safeguards and creating new means of differentiation and agency at the congregational level.
Between now and the December 2 Full Council meeting, Vintage elders will use those two weeks to diligently pray and seek further input from staff, deacons, and members. Vintage members interested in talking more about this or asking questions can contact any Vintage elder to do so; they would welcome the input and dialogue.
MODEL CONVERSATION as of 11/13
* Updates regarding the November 4th staff and elder meeting.
The staff, board, and elders met November 4th to consider the current state of and potential options for our church model. We discussed the benefits of the way we’ve operated as well as the varying difficulties that have emerged over time. Zach Cochran, a church model and strategy consultant, moderated those conversations and then shared a variety of potential paths forward. It was extremely beneficial to get everything out in the open.
Since the meeting, the staff and elders have met in their local settings to debrief, pray, and respond. Additionally, the board met to do the same. Our next steps are as follows: On November 17th, the elders will gather to pray and seek the wisdom of the Lord. Local elder teams will be looking to receive thoughts and feedback from staff, deacons, and congregants over the next couple of weeks. Our hope is to make a decision on the path forward the first week of December.
MODEL CONVERSATION as of 11/2
1. What are we considering?
By “model” we mean the structure or shape of our church organization. For 17 years, Vintage Church has been a “multisite” church, meaning one church across multiple locations, and this is reflected in our various leadership and staff structures. However, we are taking this opportunity to reflect on and affirm how exactly we would like to be structured as a church. We have collected external and internal perspectives on this, and we are exploring the long-term sustainability of our current model and other relevant options.
2. Why does this matter?
This conversation is important for us now and in the future because our model reflects our convictions and values, encoding them into our leadership structures and determining how we operate. This year has presented us with ample opportunity to consider what might increase the health and sustainability of our church and our church’s ministry, and fundamental to that consideration is the model within which we operate.
3. Where are we in the process?
Juan Maclean (Associate Pastor at Downtown Raleigh) and Phil Lauria (Associate Pastor at Durham) have worked internally with staff and elders and externally with church contacts and consultants to incorporate a variety of perspectives.
On Wednesday, November 4, our elders and staff will gather for an All-Hands meeting to better understand our current church model, explore options for the future, and consider a process for making and implementing a decision. Zach Cochran, Vice President of Operations at The Gospel Coalition, will lead the presentation, bringing years of experience in church leadership, organizational health, and multisite church models.
4. Who is involved?
All leadership bodies at Vintage—the Full Council of Elders, the Board, and the Leadership Team—as well as our full staff and Zach Cochran will provide input throughout the process. The final decision rests with the Full Council of Elders.
5. What's next?
Considering the weight of the possible decisions at hand, the elders will take a month to prayerfully work through various layers of input and review. Following the November 4 All-Hands meeting, our elders will take two weeks to hear from staff, deacons, and Board members. The Full Council will convene again on November 17 for further deliberation, then enter into another two weeks of discussion, feedback, and prayer. We anticipate a final vote taking place on December 2.
6. How can I participate or ask questions?
Please be in prayer for our church as a whole and our leaders as we listen, learn, and consider what is next for our church. Pray for wisdom, unity, and love to guide us as we chart a path forward together. If you have any questions, concerns, or input, please reach out to Juan, Phil, or any elder at your Vintage location.
GUIDEPOST ASSESSMENT as of 11/2
1. What are we considering?
Vintage Church engaged Guidepost Solutions, an independent third-party organization, to conduct an assessment of our church’s leadership, organizational culture, and practices. The assessment was commissioned following the discovery of misconduct by our former Lead Pastor and the significant questions it raised about our church’s leadership, culture, and accountability. While individuals bear responsibility for their own actions, we also want to understand whether aspects of our organizational culture, leadership structures, or practices contributed to an environment in which misconduct could occur or continue without being appropriately identified or addressed. The purpose of this assessment is to help us better understand areas of strength, identify concerns and opportunities for improvement, and consider what changes may be needed to strengthen the health and accountability of Vintage Church.
2. Why does this matter?
The health of our church involves more than our ministries and Sunday gatherings. It also includes how we lead, how we care for people, how decisions are made, and how we respond when concerns are raised. One important question is whether aspects of our culture, leadership practices, or the ways our theological convictions have been applied have discouraged women from speaking up, limited their opportunities to contribute, or prevented their concerns from being heard and taken seriously. More broadly, we want to understand whether our leadership and accountability structures have served our church well and where they may need to change. We are not presuming what Guidepost will find. Rather, we want to approach this independent assessment with humility, openness, and a willingness to examine difficult questions. Our hope is that what we learn will help us build a healthier church, strengthen trust, and ensure our practices reflect our mission and values.
3. Where are we in the process?
Guidepost has completed the initial survey and is currently conducting its final interviews. Once those interviews are complete, Guidepost will compile the information gathered and prepare its findings and recommendations. We anticipate receiving Guidepost’s final report before the end of November 2026. The report will be shared with church members, and Guidepost will participate in opportunities to present its findings, explain its process, and answer questions.
4. Who is involved?
Guidepost Solutions is responsible for conducting the independent assessment and presenting its findings. Vintage’s elders and organizational leadership are responsible for reviewing the findings, considering recommendations, and determining appropriate next steps within their respective areas of responsibility. The experiences and perspectives of staff, members, and others who have participated in the assessment are an important part of this process.
5. What's next?
We anticipate receiving Guidepost’s final report in November 2026 and sharing with the church shortly after. Following the presentation of the findings, church leadership will carefully consider what we have learned, evaluate the recommendations, identify areas requiring attention, and determine appropriate actions and priorities. We recognize that receiving and sharing the report is only the beginning of this next phase. Our desire is not simply to acknowledge concerns but to respond thoughtfully and meaningfully to what we learn.
6. How can I participate or ask questions?
We encourage members and attenders to stay informed, pray for wisdom and humility for our church’s leaders, and participate in opportunities for discussion and feedback as they become available. As the assessment findings are shared, we will provide additional information about opportunities to ask questions and offer input. Our desire is that this process will be marked by openness, thoughtful listening, accountability, and a willingness to respond appropriately to what we learn.
DOWNTOWN PASTOR HIRE as of 11/19
The search for our next Downtown Pastor is underway. The Search Committee has met twice and is working through its initial review of more than 35 applications. We’re encouraged by the response so far. With the holidays approaching and other important conversations underway at Vintage, this stage may take a little longer as we give each application the attention it deserves. Please pray for wisdom and discernment for the committee and for the person God is preparing to shepherd Vintage Downtown.
DOWNTOWN PASTOR HIRE as of 11/2
1. What are we considering?
Vintage will open the hiring process for a Downtown Raleigh Campus Pastor on November 1. This position is separate from the Vintage Lead Pastor position, in which Shaun Cross is still serving as an interim.
2. Why does this matter?
For Downtown, this is a critical role. We are asking God to provide a pastor who will shepherd our Downtown members, preach and teach on Sundays, lead our staff, and execute the vision and mission of Vintage Church Downtown, while also being thoughtful, caring, and ready to dive into this particular season for our church.
3. Where are we in the process?
The position is open and available here and we hope to have a robust pool of candidates within 30-60 days. We have an involved process by which candidates will be vetted and interviewed, and will visit with key leaders and members of our church.
4. Who is involved?
Tom Johnson (Elder) is chairing the Search Committee alongside Darrell Martin (Staff), Austin Howe (Board Chair), Lauren Hill (member), Natalie Carmen (Deacon), and Haily Jacobs (staff). The interview process will also include several members, staff, and leaders from Downtown.
5. What's next?
The process will be dynamic based on applications and specific candidates. While our hope is to be well under way by 2027, this hire is absolutely critical for Downtown’s next steps, so we hope to move with a sense of urgency and calm—wisdom and discernment cannot be sacrificed.
6. How can I participate or ask questions?
Pray with us and always feel free to ask where we are in the process. The Search Committee is the go-to point of contact for information as we move forward, though you can also contact any Downtown elder for more information, or to see how you might contribute to the process.
FAQs
Have any questions? Please let us know. You can email info@vintagenc.com and we will get back to you as soon as possible